Hedge Funds assets dwindle considerably Wednesday, January 21, 2009
For the industry as a whole, [albeit starting from a lower estimate than I've seen elsewhere, which may reflect that their figures do not include assets invested in fund of hedge funds] Hennessee Group has estimated that hedge fund industry assets decreased by USD782bn in 2008 to USD1.21trn, a 39% fall. They divide this up as
- USD399bn redemptions
- USD383bn drop in valuation
This is because the Madoff case has challenged the notion that the due diligence and monitoring is in any way adequate to warrant their fees. Furthermore, investors notice fees far more when performance is low or negative and will question the value added far more.
Hennessee Group Research says, fund of hedge funds were the largest single source of capital for hedge funds at 32 per cent of the total. Of direct investors in hedge funds, individuals and family offices accounted for 30 per cent, pension schemes 15 per cent, endowments and foundations 12 per cent and corporations 11 per cent.
The hit on fund of hedge funds will affect smaller and less well known funds hardest, since they tend to be weakest at marketing successfully to end investors. Whilst they may get seed money from some wealthy investors to put them in the barely viable $100m range, pushing beyond this without fund of hedge funds assistance is incredibly tough.
One firm in particular, RAB Capital, is having a bad time [not to mention investors in the company and its' funds]. Previously acclaimed, its assets under management fell 74% in 2008 to $1.9 billion at the end of December, compared to $7.2 billion a year earlier, according to Market Watch. As a result, revenues including management and performance fees fell to £51m, a drop of 59%.
Across the industry, there is also an investor backlash from hedge funds that have imposed a "gate" on investments i.e. refused to allow investors to make withdrawals, whilst still demanding their management fees on those same funds. This has been likened to being locked in a hotel room by staff and still being told you have to pay the room rate. In the good times, few investors seemed to care about their liquidity options on such investments. Now it has moved to the forefront of their mind and I anticipate more investors will demand considerably lower fees to lock their money up for long periods.
I confess to some bitterness on this matter of investor liquidity - I was involved in a venture that sought to develop a regulated secondary market for hedge funds that would enable investors to trade with each other, without necessitating redemptions from the funds. Many fund of funds firms we spoke to back in 2007 scoffed at the notion that such a mechanism was useful since "redemptions and liquidity would never be an issue" which is a genuine quote to me from the CIO at GAM. I am hoping to run into him again soon to remind him of those words.
Many hedge funds will also be quietly dying or considering exiting since the likelihood of them receiving performance fees for some years to come looks remote, given that they normally have to hit the high watermarks of past years before they qualify. Of course, management fees may tied them over, but drops in the value of assets will have also pushed these down.
If 2008 was bad for funds, my current guess is that 2009 will not be any better.
Labels: Funds, Hedge fund, Hedge Funds, Investor, secondary markets
posted by John Wilson @ 11:30 AM Permanent Link
,
![]()
newsvine
reddit
Share indices are crumbling tonight Thursday, October 09, 2008
After some frenetic trading in the last few minutes, the Dow ended the day at 8579 having smashed through the psychological barrier of 9000.
Spread-betting quotes right now i.e. Thursday 2230h are showing the FTSE100 down 200 to approximately 4113, levels last seen in 2003. Whilst the levels are based on on thin trading and without the enormous liquidity during market hours, they foretell of a large fall on the open tomorrow unless Far East markets find some reason to turn the tide.
Labels: Dow Jones Industrial Average, FTSE 100 Index, markets, secondary markets, Stock market
posted by John Wilson @ 10:14 PM Permanent Link
,
![]()
newsvine
reddit
Bidroute - a logical way to improve program trading Friday, September 19, 2008
Many people outside of the City would be surprised to know how "Heath Robinson" much of the internal systems infrastructure actually is at most companies. Spreadsheets play an integral part in many key functions and email/faxes/phone are still used in some dealings between counterparties.
One notable area of spreadsheet blizzards and emails/faxes is program trading, which refers to the execution of large baskets of shares in many companies.
When placing program trade orders, investors are keen to minimise their "market impact", by which I mean trading in a manner which adversely moving prices against oneself because the market becomes aware the trades before execution is complete. Brokers aim to assist such investors via their dedicated Program Trading desks.
The desk can either execute these baskets on an "agency" or "principal" basis. With the former, the investors continues to face the same price risk in the market, receiving the price that is achieved, but aim to reduce market impact by utilising the brokers execution facilities/expertise.
As principal, a broker buys the basket from the client without knowing its specific contents other than general characteristics e.g. number of stocks, their sectors, their approximate value. They will then aim to profit from the execution by trading it at a better price in the market, but with the obvious risk that they may fail.
An equally significant deterrent though is that orchestrating program trades can be a time-consuming and complex manual process, especially when little exists by way of standard formats to exchange information - one is constantly coping with emails flying around and spreadsheets being constructed and amended by multiple parties.
A growing difficulty for fund managers is being able to satisfactorily demonstrate to the regulators that you sought to achieve best execution [not necessarily the same as best price] on behalf of your investment clients.
BidRoute seeks to address this headache in 3 ways
- By providing a single communication hub for routing program trades to multiple counterparties and describing them in a consistent manner, which makes orchestration easier and hence lessens the burden of accessing a wider market if desired
- Offering facilities to operate a competitive auction for the program trade between brokers, which should lead to a better price being obtained via a fair and transparent process
- The platform assists in administering the trade, pre and post execution and maintaining records to demonstrate quality of the execution/service received. This is important when seeking to demonstrate why routing decision were made and highlight why price was not the only determinant in awarding a program to a particular broker.
Understandably, some brokers have been less than keen to participate in a service that would expose them to transparent price competition, albeit on an anonymous bidding basis, preferring an opaque environment. However, they have been more interested in the administrative efficiencies the platform offers, especially when dealing with hundreds of such trades per day. Knowing that the auction component was optional has made take-up on the sell side much easier.
Despite this, the buy side have not been quick to grab this opportunity for reasons that presently elude me. After all,
- there is no direct cost to them in using it
- implementation and integration looks relatively trivial, with the service utilising FIX and hooking up to major order management systems
- administration, orchestration and record keeping are simplified
- a buy-side dealer can run a price auction if they wish
- execution and service quality can be recorded and measured
Labels: bidroute, markets, program trades, secondary markets, Stock market
posted by John Wilson @ 8:28 AM Permanent Link
,
![]()
newsvine
reddit
Getmein - hypocracy and lunacy in a single venue Wednesday, July 16, 2008
Whilst emailing some friends about the possibility of going along to one or more of the concerts being held at Excel alongside the British Motor Show, I saw a Google ad for Getmein, the ticketing secondary market that was acquired by Ticketmaster.
If you recall, Ticketmaster had been vociferous in its opposition to secondary markets, strongly arguing to the UK Parliamentary select committee that such exchanges were wrong on numerous grounds, citing profiteering and exploitation of fans amongst them. Evidently, these views have been dropped now that it owns several such exchanges.
Out of curiosity, I looked up the gigs I was interested in and saw tickets were indeed listed on Getmein for the events at prices, including a 10% mark-up for Getmein, up to £82.50. Yet the primary market, in the form of See Tickets, was offering the same tickets at £30, including their £3 fee.
Since listings are free on Getmein, silly priced sale ads can be posted on Getmein with no downside and only upside if someone gullibly buys at an inflated price - or put another way if an ignorant fan parts with more money than they need to.
Don't worry, I'm not performing an about face on secondary markets, but simply noting the hypocracy of certain companies and the lunacy surrounding the opaque nature of the ticketing market.
Most noteworthy was the accompanying T&Cs on the See Tickets booking page.
All tickets purchased on this site are governed by our terms and conditions. In particular, we draw your attention to the fact that all tickets are for personal use only and cannot be resold under any circumstances. Resale or attempted resale is grounds for seizure or cancellation without refund or other compensation. The Event Partner and its affiliates, successors, or assigns may enforce these terms in accordance with the provisions of the Contracts (Rights of Third Parties) Act 1999 (the Act).
So Ticketmaster seems to be complicit in breaching such conditions, a matter that it presumably understands.
Separately, the US division of Ticketmaster is now issuing paperless tickets citing consumer convenience and the disruption to touts as being major reasons for their introduction. Unfortunately, this has met a considerable consumer backlash, in the main because they have continued to charge the same high level of fees despite the evident savings from paperless ticketing and because people recognise it has damaged their ability to transfer the tickets should they need to.
Labels: Getmein, secondary markets, ticketing, Ticketmaster
posted by John Wilson @ 11:09 PM Permanent Link
,
![]()
newsvine
reddit
![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](http://img.zemanta.com/reblog_e.png?x-id=139c2dd6-bcea-4efa-859d-8b102c4851ff)
![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](http://img.zemanta.com/reblog_e.png?x-id=040e6822-2d53-4f17-a0bc-ad8cba38255a)
![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](http://img.zemanta.com/reblog_e.png?x-id=1d59f691-b8d6-4aec-8ed1-698485f302c4)















