John Thain quits Bank of America Thursday, January 22, 2009
Perhaps the "icing" on the cake was the news that John Thain's new office had been lavishly re-furbished e.g. waste bin for $1,400 and a rug for $87,000, which isn't the sort of thing that goes well with tax payers or politicians who've just bailed out your company.
Merrill's staff should have cause to be thankful to Thain. He
- found them a safe-ish harbour in the storms and thus avoided the fate that befell Lehman
- negotiated a good deal with Bank of America despite Merrill's awful prospects, as borne out by their Q4 results
- paid their bonuses in December, totalling over $4bn despite the huge losses, which was some two months earlier than usual and days ahead of Bank of America taking over
Might John Thain follow his former colleague, Hank Paulson into academia and avoid the hassle of commercial life? Paulson has just stepped down as US Treasury Secretary and can easily afford not to work again. Similarly Thain is unlikely to be pressured by the need to work again, even without any payoff he may receive from Bank of America. However, his talents are widely recognised and it is probable that a number of firms are already weighing up the possibility of engaging him in some capacity after a short break, especially in the private equity sector where he could avoid much public scrutiny.
Any payoff he does receive will be a matter of public disclosure because Bank of America is listed. So it will be interesting to see whether he extracts one final huge "pound of flesh", despite the company having only just received a huge bailout. For Bank of America any sizeable payout will be a PR disaster since it will clearly be described as a payment for failure that has been funded by the taxpayer. However, John Thain probably has a pretty watertight employment contract under which he will inevitably be entitled to some pre-determined payoff. I also doubt that Ken Lewis will press any case that Thain was dismissed for misconduct or something similar, regardless of his personal feelings, since this would embroil the Bank in far too much unwelcome press over a protracted period, as each side makes disclosures helpful to their case.
Thain could, of course, choose to forego a payoff in recognition of the climate as he evidently decided to do with his bonus. Yet having conceded over his bonus to save face for Ken Lewis, he may be less inclined to do so given the manner of his departure. Watch this space.
Meanwhile, I hear his successor could be inheriting a nice new office.
Labels: Bank of America, Hank Paulson, John Thain, Ken Lewis, Merrill Lynch
posted by John Wilson @ 7:59 PM Permanent Link
,
![]()
newsvine
reddit
Can John Thain remain at Bank of America? Friday, January 16, 2009
Image by Getty Images via DaylifeThe credit crunch has unravelled the reputations of some of the previously most respected investment banking bosses. Previously praised for their deal-making abilities, business savvy and genius, many have been undone by the collapse of their empires e.g. Dick Fuld. Yet of all of those in the spotlight I have perhaps been most astonished by the apparent fall from grace of two former Goldman Sachs senior figures, Hank Paulson and John Thain. Regarded in awe within and outside of the firm, they were credited with steering Goldman on an prosperous course for a number of years.Hank Paulson, as the US Treasury Secretary, appeared to have the perfect CV to design and oversee the actions of the US administration given his extensive experience on Wall Street. Yet he has been widely derided for his handling of the situation and notably the hastily arranged TARP.
Meanwhile John Thain, who was only parachuted in Merrill Lynch at the end of 2007, and who appeared to have cleverly manoeuvred his "ship" into the safe harbour of Bank of America is now being castigated for the issues being uncovered in the Merrill Lynch balance sheet that weren't declared up front. The Bank of America has now received a further $20bn capital injection from the US Government to ensure it remain adequately capitalised. Trust in Thain by his boss, Ken Lewis, was already strained following the furore over bonus claims the Merrill executives were allegedly going to request, as well as the awful Q4 performance by Merrill.
When your current boss thinks you hoodwinked him, regardless of the fact you were acting for Merrill shareholders at the time in soliciting the best price, your position is surely shaky. Having been in charge of the "ship" for a year, Lewis may also question whether Thain has demonstrated he can turn things around quickly enough at Merrill, especially given the state they have now apparently inherited.
Separately, the FT are also raising the question of whether the bonuses paid to Merrill staff in Q408 could come under scrutiny if it turns out Merrill was technically insolvent at the time the BofA deal closed. If Merrill staff weren't already panicked by fear of layoffs, the prospect of having to repay bonuses should really make their day.
Labels: Bank of America, goldman sachs, Hank Paulson, John Thain, Merrill Lynch
posted by John Wilson @ 12:04 PM Permanent Link
,
![]()
newsvine
reddit
IT contractors get squeezed Thursday, October 30, 2008
Following moves by RBS, Barclays, Deutsche Bank, Merrill Lynch and Nomura in demanding their IT contractors take a 10% pay-cut or lose the possibility of a contract renewal, JP Morgan has now demanded a 15% cut or else face being given notice.
In the current market, most contractors will have little choice but to agree, given the scarcity of roles available elsewhere.
Labels: JPMorgan Chase, Merrill Lynch, Royal Bank of Scotland
posted by John Wilson @ 3:42 PM Permanent Link
,
![]()
newsvine
reddit
Credit teams are the real villians of the financial crisis Monday, September 22, 2008
Credit lines are an essential part of the liquidity portfolio for brokers and if they are removed that does two things
- it immediately constrains the ability of the broker to trade and may force them to reduce positions at a time when forced sales will exacerbate their financial woes
- it sends a clear message that confidence has been lost and that news travels fast, causing further "panic" and prompting either asset withdrawals by investors or tightening of credit lines by other firms, all concerned about being left with nothing
- it impedes the company's ability to raise further capital
- it generates a loss of confidence in the company - a share price reflects views on a company, which in turn triggers more direct effects e.g. withdrawal of deposits
- a re-examination of a company by a credit rating agency, which in turn may downgrade the company and prompt further problems
In case you think I am picking on commercial banks, brokers have their own credit teams who do the very same thing and will readily cut the trading lines of a client if there is a hint of a problem.
Labels: Bank of America, Lehman Brothers, Merrill Lynch
posted by John Wilson @ 8:26 AM Permanent Link
,
![]()
newsvine
reddit
Now Morgan Stanley - what next, Goldman? Thursday, September 18, 2008
Every "given" during my working life has been torn to shreds this week. A week ago it would have been unthinkable for these firms to be considered vulnerable. But a day seems an eternity right now and news has emerged in the last 16 hours that Morgan Stanley is already in talks with Wachovia Bank, presumably on the basis that its' management know it may not survive being in the spotlight for long. If this goes through, that leaves just Goldman Sachs - the most respected firm in wholesale markets. Can they withstand the spotlight and hold the hounds at bay - if anyone can give you a categoric answer, then I doubt they know what they are talking about, given the climate we are in.
Along with many others, I have spent the last week in a shock. When the dust settles, it will be a very different [financial] world we face. The game is changing very quickly and the power base of London and New York may have been fundamentally undermined. This leaves open the possibility of markets shifting, especially with the growing might of sovereign wealth funds. International money can move easily and people follow money. Many other places stand very ready to welcome both.
Labels: Bank of America, goldman sachs, Lehman Brothers, markets, Merrill Lynch, Morgan Stanley, Stock market, Wachovia
posted by John Wilson @ 8:24 AM Permanent Link
,
![]()
newsvine
reddit
John Thain - serial job hopper? Monday, September 15, 2008
Still, there will be something to ease any discomfort or difficulties he may face. According to the New York Times, with this deal, his employment contract change of control clause will be triggered, and he will exit Merrill after merely ten months on the job with $25-million in total compensation, which included a $15m joining fee. It would have been more but most of his options are worthless.
Luckily for him he also left NYSE with just under $20-million not quite a year ago. Nice work/unemployment if you can get it.
Labels: John Thain, Merrill, Merrill Lynch
posted by John Wilson @ 9:29 PM Permanent Link
,
![]()
newsvine
reddit
Merrill 2008 hiring freeze memo Monday, August 18, 2008
- positions where budget has already been allocated
- permanent, contract and temporary positions, and includes replacement hires
- contract renewals are forbidden
That should ensure there will be hordes of recruitment agents crying into old job specs reminiscing about the good old days.
Labels: Merrill Lynch
posted by John Wilson @ 2:25 PM Permanent Link
,
![]()
newsvine
reddit
Clearing in Europe is going to heat up Friday, August 15, 2008
European Central Counterparty Limited (EuroCCP) launches tomorrow with 15 clearing firms, including the 9 founding members of Turquoise.
The Turquoise firms are Credit Suisse, Deutsche Bank, Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley, Merrill Lynch, Citi, UBS, BNP Paribas and Societe Generale. The others are ABN Amro, Barclays Capital, Credit Agricole Cheuvreux, Instinet, KAS Bank and Lehman Brothers.
Of the 15 firms, 6 are general clearing participants who will be able to clear and settle trades for trading firms who are not EuroCCP clearers. The remainder will be clearing and settling their own trades.
Owned by DTCC, this is a overseas significant expansion by the US outfit, albeit it has taken them many years to land a large contract despite having had people on the ground in Europe for many years. It will undoubtedly create an even more competitive landscape in the central clearer market. Moreover, DTCC has deep pockets to fund its efforts thanks to its US revenues.
Labels: ABN Amro, Barclays Capital, BNP Paribas, Deutsche Bank, goldman sachs, Lehman Brothers, Merrill Lynch, Morgan Stanley
posted by John Wilson @ 12:00 PM Permanent Link
,
![]()
newsvine
reddit
Merrill UK will be expanding - to absorb those tax losses
Bad news for the UK Government tax receipts, but hopefully good news for City workers who have been taking a battering over the last 12 months.
Labels: Merrill Lynch
posted by John Wilson @ 11:53 AM Permanent Link
,
![]()
newsvine
reddit
Huge Wall St settlement for Auction Rate Securities "Victims" Friday, August 08, 2008
Citigroup is to buy $7.5bn worth of ARS from retail investors in the next three months while Merrill Lynch announced that it would buy back ARS it sold to investors starting next year. There are currently $12bn of such holdings but Merrill said it expected there would be $10bn by the time it begins its buy-back. Meanwhile, UBS was on Thursday night close to finalising the details of its own deal with regulators.
Apparently Citi also has to pay a $100m fine to settle claims from regulators that it had misrepresented ARS as liquid, cash-like securities.
I previously wrote about the ARS market here.
These are staggering deals, imposed by the regulator to "protect" Main Street from being financially injured.
Prior to markets seizing up, ARS markets were indeed very liquid and paid higher returns to investors than bank deposits, with rates set through an auction clearing process. To my knowledge, relatively few investors suffered any capital losses since the lenders remained solvent. What disappeared was the liquidity that enabled people to release cash by selling their holdings i.e. buyers simply disappeared regardless of rates on offer. Lenders, as a consequence of being unable to refinance elsewhere, were also unable to buy back the securities despite the punitive rates many of them were obliged to pay under the terms of the securities.
The penalities / settlement redresses two issues
1) Wall Street brokers failed to alert people to the fact that the markets were becoming increasingly illiquid i.e. negligent in their duty to clients. Obviously had they done so, that would have simply accelerated the collapse in such markets.
2) The banks themselves took advantage of clients by offloading increasingly illiquid stock onto them, prompted by internal risk concerns, whilst maintaining their stance that there were no problems.
What is most disturbing about this episode is that an efficient cash market and the related instrument has been irreputably harmed to the detriment of future borrowers and lenders alike.
Labels: auction rate securities, Citigroup, Merrill Lynch, UBS AG, Wall Street
posted by John Wilson @ 10:15 AM Permanent Link
,
![]()
newsvine
reddit
![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](http://img.zemanta.com/reblog_e.png?x-id=dd6a1ef0-89b2-4d83-b690-47d73da0d618)
![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](http://img.zemanta.com/reblog_e.png?x-id=a374ad34-7d70-4539-98f2-6cbfbf4e9eb4)
![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](http://img.zemanta.com/reblog_e.png?x-id=089ef702-d6a9-403d-85d6-dff644f4e7b7)
![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](http://img.zemanta.com/reblog_e.png?x-id=587d1219-1561-4717-bc5b-c8f70c2152fe)
![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](http://img.zemanta.com/reblog_e.png?x-id=72ddb4a1-411b-4544-a1d7-457302b35053)
![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](http://img.zemanta.com/reblog_e.png?x-id=b7f404b2-4a66-4029-bed4-af96f1b0e33a)
![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](http://img.zemanta.com/reblog_e.png?x-id=9a1ccb31-43e1-42e7-a1d8-97205fb51f04)
![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](http://img.zemanta.com/reblog_e.png?x-id=4c784a5d-76e9-449b-94a3-b0e1c3d0d013)
![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](http://img.zemanta.com/reblog_e.png?x-id=7f2d745a-5a7f-4864-85a9-64fee11c165c)















